Who do you think Dylan's soulmate was? For me, it's a no-brainer, definitely Brenda. Their chemistry, passion, and intensity was palpable, and I don't think any other couple or girl Dylan was paired up with could compare to the chemistry and spark they had. I don't think there was a woman who loved Dylan more than Brenda did. She turned herself lied, snuck around, and defied her parents for him. Hell, she practically changed his life.
I never bought the Dylan and Kelly crap for a minute(they didn't even talk or were that close when Brandon and Brenda came to town), I just think he picked her over Brenda because she was an easy way out and he was sick and tired of Jim being on his case all the time. I always felt that after Brenda left, they were trying to push the whole Dylan/Kelly soulmates crap down my throat. Maybe there was sexual attraction and lust, but there was never that spark or love, like Dylan and Brenda had.
I hated him when he cheated on Brenda with Kelly and picked her over Brenda. I also hated the way he treated her during that whole decision time, she did not deserve that. I think I bawled my eyes out when they finally broke up and Brenda was crying in her room, listening to "Losing My Religion," by R.E.M., heartbreaking scene.
I liked him with Toni too, felt sorry for him when she died. Extremely heartbreaking scene. They had great chemistry. She kind of reminded me of Brenda.